(This piece is cross-posted at Desi Critics)
I will never have a washboard-flat stomach no matter how many sit-ups I do. And these hips are here to stay. I can’t help it, I’m Punjabi.
I recently saw a photo of Demi Moore at 43 and a TV advert for some torturous exercise contraption featuring a 50-year old woman (or “grandmother” as they kept calling her). They both had skinny, rock-hard bodies and ageless faces as they strutted in their scanties. It made me droop with exhaustion thinking of the standards they represented as normal for the average woman and desirable to the average man. When is it going to be okay for a girl to become a woman who fills out & ages anyway?
Remember film legends Sridevi & Babra Sharif who enticed us to follow them over the green hills of Bollywood & Lollywood screens? They wore clothes that enhanced and hugged their womanly figures and millions adored their voluptuous beauty.
It used to be that South Asian girls had busts and hips, and, in fact, lived in the hopes of developing them. They filled out a sari or shalvar kameez properly. They saw Moghul miniatures, temple carvings, homegrown actresses and models, and heck, the Aunties all around them and knew that a buxom beauty lay within their reach. Nay, it was their genetic destiny.
But that was before the Murdochization of South Asia & the accompanying pre-adolescent body ideal invasion.
Although certainly not as bad as the Kate Moss rage in the West, desi women from the silver screen on down are feeling the pinch as they try to squeeze themselves into smaller and smaller sizes. Bony socialites and models are in, tall slim beauty queens compete for international titles (the only difference between them being skin color and even then none are too dark), actresses retire just so that they can finally eat, and everyone is perpetually on a diet or exercise machine - most often simultaneously. And to have a bust now is simply passé.
It wasn’t so long ago that a little extra weight delighted everyone & was termed “healthy.” Oh, Pinkie? Yes, I saw her yesterday. She’s become so healthy, na! Give me the old days when a woman dug into her parathas with relish. When Lollywood Punjabi film heroine Anjuman frolicked like a baby elephant around mustachioed, bloodshot-eyed, & equally-large Sultan Rahi. When a girl relaxed into fertile belly posture immediately after marriage out of sheer relief to have got all that over with.
Remember delicious desi aunties? The ones who elbowed you out of the way as they attacked wedding buffet tables with zeal? You can see them on the video afterwards, setting their plates on their stomachs (which double as tables) & throwing gnawed bones over their shoulders with abandon & little concern for the cameras. They revel in maintaining their deliciousness and have the deep satisfaction of offering that much more of themselves to the world to love.
Delicious desi aunties still exist everywhere in spite of skinny desi “blondes.” And I’ll tell you a little secret: they exist inside of you. You can huff and puff on those machines and deny yourself the dosa but somewhere along the way you too will embrace and celebrate your genetic destiny – just like Sridevi and Babra did.
Now, pass me that chicken tikka - and hold the salad!







19 comments
Comments feed for this article
January 28, 2006 at 6:38 am
izzymo
Salaamz,
Wow, that old Desi desirable woman sure sounds nice. And those actresses are beautiful. It’s really a shame that women are being forced to fit into this impossible ideal. And honestly, maybe it’s because of my old art school days, but flat bellies don’t really impress me. There was one pop star who’s abs were so flat, they looked like a man’s! They were all hard and muscle-ly. Not very feminine at all. Eww. By the way, who is the artist on the painting? Is it Gustav Klimt?
January 28, 2006 at 6:42 am
Baji
“They revel in maintaining their deliciousness and have the deep satisfaction of offering that much more of themselves to the world to love.”
Hon, when can I read your name in the New Yorker?
January 28, 2006 at 7:16 am
eteraz
dude,
there’s nothing hotter in this world than a thick desi girl.
alhamdulillah AND inshallah!
January 28, 2006 at 8:36 am
Aisha
LOL. *aisha gives dear baraka a standing ovaction* This was truly delightful and came at a good time for me
January 28, 2006 at 9:05 pm
koonj
Oh perfect!!
Thank you, Baraka for giving the pregnant lady something to hold on to. And I have a blog entry in my drafts that will follow up on this discussion. Seems like we’re thinking about the same stuff.
Yes, I remember Babra Sharif and Anjuman. And I’m really annoyed by the sight of rail-thin desi starlets that all look the same.
January 29, 2006 at 3:06 am
sepoy
ALL i want to ask is why is that rubenesque beauty not desi?
was Anjuman’s picture that hard to find?
January 29, 2006 at 3:41 am
Leila M.
ahhh great post! By the way, those voluptuous examples tend to be what I consider to be NORMAL! When I think of overweight, my notion is something faaar larger than the examples given here. In fact, I may dare to say that they would be more on the skinny side in my book. Then again, I’m along the lines of old Egyptian movie belly dancerish, myself
January 29, 2006 at 5:47 am
Um Mahtab
Round, plump and sweet like a ladoo!
January 29, 2006 at 12:33 pm
Saeed
you’re talking of the old sri devi…u shuld see her in her last movie “Judai”- http://www.cyberadsstudio.com/bollywood/chamakte/judai.gif she was competing with urmila matondkar there…lol!
January 30, 2006 at 12:10 pm
mayya
lol that was a cute post! Don’t worry we still have lots of those aunties around here still who shove their way towards the wedding dinner tables but then when it comes to finding a bahu she has to be thin, slim like a stick
Our lollywood heroines are still fat, there’s saima who can compare to anjuman, well a lil bit and works with heros who look like her sons :s
January 30, 2006 at 8:32 pm
Dil-E-Nadaan
Absolutely loved it!
January 31, 2006 at 4:14 am
Baraka
Salaam all!
Saeed & Mayya, my references are from the late 80s/early 90s because I stopped watching Hindi films for the most part after that. But that didn’t stop me from noticing how curiously thin a lot of the actresses were getting!
Sepoy - Whenever I did a google search for voluptuous desi women I got some er, unusable results so decided to go with Flaming June until I could track a couple down.
UmMahtab: That sums it up perfectly!
General:
For me the the globalization of narrow beauty ideals is very troubling. Women should celebrate who they are instead of trying to force themselves into someone else’s mould.
And, while a balanced diet & exercise are important, incessant gymming, obsessive weighing, & endless salads are just plain tiresome!
Warmly,
Baraka
January 31, 2006 at 9:54 am
DrMaxtor
When all else fails, theres the DrM diet plan. Theres a reason the American Diabetic society vouches for it.
February 1, 2007 at 12:33 am
Gaurav
lovely post.
February 1, 2007 at 12:36 am
Gaurav
Ah, pressed publish too soon. While I agree that the Kate Mossian standards that western media has portrayed as being acceptable are putting pressure on everyone, but even western societies are rejecting these fake ideals. Look at all the rejections of models with eating disorders or too skinny figures in American and European fashion industry. I don’t think South Asian media will get to that stage. We love our food and the curves on our women too much.
May 12, 2008 at 10:41 pm
Delicious Desi Aunties « other|matters
[...] - Originally posted in Rickshaw Diaries [...]
June 5, 2008 at 7:29 pm
Hips don’t lie « Achelois
[...] too is a sad mix between NoorJehan and Umm Kulthoom which means we become very conscious when anyone talks about curves even those related to mathematical [...]
June 6, 2008 at 12:43 pm
Shahrzad
lol, i never like those Hollywood Skinny women. They seem just like artifical statues. Along with dosen of sergerious they do to be “ageless”.
I love my body, whatever it is. Bcs it’s natural and it’s all about me..
June 8, 2008 at 12:56 am
mummyjaan
What a delicious article. It delighted an overweight, “curvy” me.
The only thing in the post that put me off was description of your desi aunties whose “stomachs doubled as tables”. Hahaha. It’s nice to be a little ‘healthy’ and tuck in from time to time, but that description has taken away my appetite for the day :D!